In May of 1998, Craig Venter announced
that he was going to create a private company to map out the entire human
genome (Shreeve 6). People could not imagine this
ever happening, considering how big the human genome is but, if he did so they
knew it would be a huge scientific achievement.
It could lead to treatments for diseases. It would allow doctors to get a better look
at what genes are the cause of different diseases. It would lead to more accurate medicines and
understanding of the human organism alone.
But as the human genome project is completed and technology becomes more
advanced, the prices for receiving an individualized genetic test will go down
and people will be more likely to get them done just because they can and they’re
curious about their genetics.
The future of the genetic field
would lead to license-like plastic cards which would hold a chip that contained
the person’s entire genetic code. Venter
said these cards would hold information that would be key to these people’s
lives. Imagine Jeff’s card (random
person) which says if he smoked he would have a 37% chance of developing lung
cancer before he was sixty years old, so he didn’t smoke. He knew that aspirin would help him prevent
heart disease, so he would take aspirin especially since he had the defective
gene APOE, which puts him at a higher risk for heart attacks and strokes. This would therefore change the way he ate
and exercised on a daily basis. The card
would tell him what his chances of going insane or committing suicide would
be (Shreeve 8,9). It would tell him a bunch of other
random little bits of information as well which could ultimately change the way
Jeff lived his life.
Not only would people be able to
change their lives based on the genetic coding, but other people have the
possibility of being able to change their lives as well. The misuse of genetic information is a scary
thing to imagine. Even though Venter
thought a lot about the success of the human genome code, he also thought a lot
about the possible exploitation of it as well.
If a person has a certain APOE gene, they will not necessarily develop
Alzheimer’s but have an increased risk in developing the disease. What if there was a similar gene, where the
person had an increased risk, not an automatic fixed occurrence, in becoming a
pedophile? Would the law enforcement put everyone with that gene in jail, even
though some of those people may not necessarily become pedophiles? (Shreeve 217)
Sometimes, I think the human genome
is a beautiful thing. The possibilities
of finding genes where diseases lie and possible cures for said diseases is
amazing. But sometimes, the thought of
it scares me. Knowing everything about
yourself and also knowing the possibilities of the future that may not even
occur. Although it may be helpful in
some cases to know the possibilities, it may also make some people go crazy,
wondering if it will happen and when it will happen.
There was a quote in the book that
I found and it immediately made me wonder about all the possibilities with the
human genome and what the future will look like as technology furthers. Craig Venter said, “My solution would be to
change the Fourteenth Amendment. Instead
of saying you cannot discriminate on the basis of race, creed, gender, or
whatever, it should just say you can’t be discriminated against on the basis of
genetic information, period. Because
that covers everything else” (Shreeve 217).
Sources:
Shreeve, James. The
Genome War: How Craig Venter Tried to Capture the Code of Life and Save the
World. New York: Ballantine, 2005. Print.
I like your comment about being scared of knowing everything about yourself that your genetic code could provide. Personally, I would rather not know what my genome is, because I feel like I would constantly be living in fear of what health issue I would develop. Yes it could be helpful in specific cases, but if I went through everyday life knowing what percentages of health risks I have, it would put a lot of restrictions on the way I lived. I would be better off making any free choice I wanted instead of always determining my actions based on whether it could be potentially harmful to me.
ReplyDeleteKnowing your entire genome and the implications of certain genes is daunting. How would you live life fully if you are constantly worrying about possible health complications? There are medical benefits to knowing what diseases you are prone to acquire, but I believe that the emotional stress may be too much for most people, if not all. Personally, I would not like a list of all my chances for certain diseases because there is always a possibility that it may not happen. I would most likely worry about every little detail that is present in my life and not enjoy life itself. I think it's knowing how my life may turn out, rather than unknowing, that would stop me from decoding my genome since the future would be a constant worry.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that the thought of people, especially insurance companies, having my genetic information is scary and a cause for concern. I am on the fence about knowing my genome. I would like to know what steps I can take to prevent cancer, heart disease, and other fatal conditions, but I also would not want to know that I may get Alzheimer's because that isn't preventable which means I'd be constantly freaking out every time I forget the simplest thing. I would not want to live life like that.
ReplyDeleteThis post reminds me a lot of the movie Gattaca. If employers and insurance companies had access to a person's potential of developing certain diseases, it would lead to a significant amount of employment discrimination based on genetics. In my opinion, genetic testing leads to more problems than it is worth in most cases. It seems most of the prevention methods(eating healthy and staying active) are the advice you would otherwise receive from doctors anyways without testing and the constant worry of the likelihood of developing some disease. Living in fear, seems worse than just taking precautions in the first place.
ReplyDelete